Saturday, March 27, 2010

No One Ever Got Rich Over Estimating What The American Public Wants To Taste!

(I decided to post early because there is five blogs you all will have to comment on and it may be more convenient time wise for you:)

The movie Working Girl can be related to what we have already been discussing about this past week on social class. This movie provides great representation of what we have seen in People Like Us and read in Fussell’s book about the differences between social classes.
I believe Tess makes up the lower middle class of Staten Island. She lives in a small apartment with her boyfriend, rides the Staten Island Ferry to work, uses taxis, or walks to where she wants to go. Like most females in her office, Tess works a typical lower ranking job, as a secretary for two male managers that hardly have time to see her or care about what she says. Tess is educated, friendly, and well known at work but she cant seem to get into the EntrĂ©e Program. In the movie her managers think it is because she is “up against Harvard and Morgan grads” and her five years of night schooling, honors degree, secretarial time, and Christian Lyons Test don’t measure up to get her the job she wants. Here it is evident that Tess may have been over looked possibly because they employer has pinpointed her into a certain class and does not like how or where she has obtained her higher education from.
Katherine Parker is an upper middle class woman who is at the top of her department, mergers and acquisitions, at the firm Petty Marsh. When she arrives the office grows silent, the workers scramble to get back to their desks, and sit down to look like they are working. Katherine seems to have her head on straight, enjoys spending her money, boss’s people around, establishes ground rules, enjoys looking attractive, and likes impressing her other male colleagues.
Tess lands a new secretarial job for Katherine and discovers how different it is than what she is used to. This is the first time Tess has worked for a woman, been encouraged to share her thoughts, and viewed a manager as a possible mentor. Katherine never asks Tess about her educational background or about other secretarial experiences but instead expects Tess to do her job well, and live up to the standards she expects. Katherine believes Tess should be, “ tough when it’s wanted, accommodating when you can be, accurate, punctual, and never make a promise you cant keep.” She views Tess as “Her link to the outside world” suggesting Tess must handle the little people and make Katherine look good while doing it. Katherine persuades Tess to accept the same views she has on life by saying things like, “watch me Tess, learn from me,” and “ You don’t get anywhere in this world by waiting for what you want to come too you, you make it happen!” The way Katherine talks to Tess reminds me of the lady in People Like Us-How to Marry the Rich and how she was telling the other women how to dress, act,stand ect.
After Katherine’s skiing accident Tess soon learns how an upper middle class woman often lives. In the movie Tess walks around Katherine’s house admiring her possessions such as her artwork, make up, exercise bike, jewelry, and clothing. Her friend Cyn equally becomes mesmerized by the house the big chandelier, and how much one of the dresses costs. Tess moves into the house and begins living her life as if she is in a higher class, which allows other people to view her differently- just like people in Fussell's book. Mick even tells her she looks “different and classy” when he sees her at the engagement party. She wears Katherine’s expensive clothing, says things that Katherine typically would, and even goes to two events Katherine is invited to. She even uses what she has learned from Katherine to attract a handsome investment broker and says things like, “I have a head for business and a body for sin.” She doesn't think twice about going to see Mr. Trask at his daughters wedding reception, just so she can get her foot in the door. Showing up to the Union Club and being in the presence of Owen Trask seems to overwhelm her.
At the end of the movie Tess learns that her true job as Katherine’s secretary may not have even allowed her to present her idea. Katherine makes a big deal by storming into their meeting and stating “She is my secretary!” This alone shocks everyone and Mr. Trask is embarrassed because a secretary has tricked him.
Tess identifies her class and low ranking job by telling Jack “ If he knew she was a secretary he would have never booked a meeting with her.” She even tells Owen Trask, “ Well no one was going to listen, not to me. I mean you can bend the rules plenty when you get upstairs, but not while your trying to get there, and if your someone like me, you cant get there without bending the rules.”
This movie gives pure examples of the different individuals that make up the hierarchy of business and of social class. One newly recent reality show, Undercover Boss, is the complete opposite of the overall just of this movie. High Executives of a particular company are disguised and are put to work in the companies lower ranking jobs. These executives learn how the employees are treated and how dangerous, and hard these jobs are for individuals. At the end of the show they often reveal the true identity of these executives and they make changes to their company that benefit the little people that make things happen.If you haven't seen this show I would recommend it.-Sunday night's on CBS (channel 12) @ 9p.m.

7 comments:

  1. this movie reminds me of the show How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying except for the fact that she had to try and she wasn't as successful in her attempt as the main guy in this show. it just shows how hard it can be in trying to climb a corporate ladder, and how many hoops you have to jump through just to get your foot into the door.
    i was wanting to watch that Undercover boss. it looks like a great show. when i was saw the commercials for the show i thought it's about time that the fat cats got a taste of what they're inflicting onto their workers. because personally i hate corporate business, i hate the hierarchy of it all. the quality of everything has lowered in the past 50-100 some years all in the name of profits. if something can save a nickel, dime, or penny they'll do it, even if it's at the cost of the value of the product. micro soft is a great example of horrible fat cats doing nothing about a problem. their XBox 360's have a horribly high failure rating, and the president acknowledged this. their rebuttal was, the consumer is still buying them so why should we worry about fixing it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In response to your blog I feel as if Tess gets wrapped up in the world of higher social class when she takes over while Katherine is injured. She is overwhelmed by all the luxuries in Katherine's house and sometimes I feel like she poses to be someone who she is not. When she had Cyn cut her hair, did this really make her more professional? Or the 6,000 doaller dress? does this classify her as higher class? I'm not so sure.

    Do not get me wrong, I do think Tess is a very smart and educated lady. If she wanted to be higher up on the corporate ladder she had every right to fulfill her dreams. The way she did it, I'm not quite sure if that was the best way to handle it. I do see where she is coming from though when she says that Mr. Trask would not even have considered her because she was a secretary.

    PS: I love Undercover Boss! Very eyeopening for some people who run companies.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I do feel like Tess is caught up in the world of higher social class while she playing Katherine, but I feel like she is also caught up in just getter her way and being heard. I think she feels all the luxuries are nice and she would appreciate them, but I feel like she is more excited about getting what she really wants. Also maybe a little revenge.

    I do agree with you that this movie is a good example of how people make up the hierarchy of business and social class. The movie might have taken it a little to the extremely, but it was very helpful getting the point across.

    I too love Undercover Boss! My family and I watch it every week! I think every company should be involved in something like what the show does!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sounds like a show I would enjoy! Its easy to dictate to others what you want them to do without having any understanding of what it is to be in their shoes. That goes both ways. But Tess is right about breaking the rules. The rules are often in place to keep order but sometimes order needs to be disrupted for a little bit of healthy change. It's good to ruffle feathers and it feels good too. But we need to recognize that though class distinctions exist, they are not static. The majority can sit by and accept what is dealt or they can challenge it. As American's we have control over a great deal of our society and we do not weild it. Social class exists because we allow it to. We will never get away from distinctions of some sort but we can still change the system over and over again if need be.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with you on so many points. I like how Katherine never once asks Tess about her education because she expects Tess to get the job done, and to do it successfully. Just because Tess didn't go to Harvard, she is still very capable to get the job done. I like how Tess handles Katherine's advice when it comes to voicing her opinion and speaking of her ideas. I think that at one point Katherine becomes very intimidated by such great ideas that Tess portrays. If Katherine didn't think that Tess had such great ideas, she wouldn't have planned to steal them and make them her own. The movie is just like People like Us-How to Marry Rich in the way that Tess dresses rich when she starts taking over her own idea and living out of Katherines house. She starts wearing $6,000 dollar clothes and changing her hairstyle just to seem upper class. Tess is a very smart woman who shouldn't need to change her apperance and her social class just to get to ideas across to Mr.Trask. Tess has had ambition from the very beginning and she obviously never stops, because showing up at Mr. Trask's duaghters wedding just to get her foot in the door, shows great ambition. Undercover boss is an amazing eye opener and just like you, I think that everyone should watch the show. One of my favorites!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have heard wonderful things about the show, but I've never seen it. I guess I really need to watch it soon! I have to say that I agree with Alex's comment, that the movie does a great job of portraying the shift in classes, but it does it in an unrealistic story. I also couldn't help but notice how many of us thought of and mentioned the People Like Us film. Specifically the part of the film which documented the "lower class" woman being coached by the "upper class" woman. While I don't necessarily agree that this is the best way to change social classes, I do think that a lot of times some kind of transformation is necessary.

    Cinderella was one story mentioned in a previous blog about Working Girl that shared similar concepts. I think that the transformation that takes place in this film is also comparable to the concept of the caterpillar-to-butterfly cycle. I also think that although Melanie Griffith is far from ugly, her character is comparable to the Ugly Duckling children's story character. Did anyone else think of parallel stories/films/books/characters?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Amanda,

    Thanks for laying the groundwork for our blog discussion here. You identify the classes that Tess and Katharine represent. You also allude to the fact that Tess class passes. By imitating Katharine in voice, dress, and lifestlye, she gets mistaken for someone who is upper class. We've talked about money being extremely important for determining one's class status, but the choices one makes that Fussell talks about regarding status are largely performative. Our identities are not stable. Rather, we perform them in how we act in public. Tess is a very convincing performer, a true student of the "fairy godmother" in People Like Us. She has no problem nabbing Harrison Ford.

    I've only seen one episode of Undercover Boss, but I'm fairly skeptical of the show. Ask yourself this question: why would a company agree to do this show? Why would Waste Management, for example, agree to humiliate their CEO on national television? Surely, the companies don't think it will harm them. In fact, they're banking on it helping them. In these hard times, companies like Waste Management are showing Americans that they care about the little people. The whole first episode struck me as a manipulative commercial. The truth is companies only care about the bottom line. Ever since Dodge v. Ford, corporations have been mandated by the law to return profits to their shareholders. They can have no other interests, unless of course these interests lead to more profits. I'd argue that Undercover Boss is a PR stint for these companies. We watch the CEO get humiliated and show some compassion to an employee or two, and we come away thinking, "That Waste Management company isn't like the rest of those soulless corporations. They actually care about their employees."

    I also noticed in the one episode I saw that middle management is scapegoated for the structural mistreatment of the lowly workers, as if middle management wasn't simply carrying out the dictates of their superiors. The higher ups end up looking like repentant sinners worthy of our sympathy and even admiration while middle management is demonized. I think it's a fairly ideological show, but I do plan on watching a few more episodes since many of you claim to enjoy it. I'd love to hear what exactly it is that you like about the show.

    ReplyDelete